What about this trade???

im in a fantasy baseball league and i want some thoughts on a proposed trade....


Billingsley, Chad SP LA


·Glaus, Troy 3B STL


·Loney, James 1B LA


·Rowand, Aaron CF SF


for


Beltran, Carlos CF NYM





I have Carlos Beltran and they offered me the others.


here is my roster





Beltran, Carlos CF NYM


Byrnes, Eric CF ARI


Soriano, Alfonso LF CHC


Damon, Johnny CF NYY


Young, Michael SS TEX


Atkins, Garrett 3B COL


Cano, Robinson 2B NYY


Youkilis, Kevin 1B BOS


McCann, Brian C ATL





pitching staff





Zambrano, Carlos SP CHC


Wainwright, Adam SP STL


Snell, Ian SP PIT


Rivera, Mariano RP NYY


Escobar, Kelvim SP ANA


Cordero, Francisco RP CIN


Bonderman, Jeremy SP DET





thanks for the help

What about this trade???
What wonderful answers so far...lol...





Well Aaron Rowand, even though had a huge season last year isn't going to produce that this year. He has no protection in the Giants line-up, and he plays in a pitchers park. Last year he played in Philly, and Rollins almost hit 30.





I don't like the trade much. Getting 4 players for 1 seems a bit odd, especially when Glaus might not even be 100%. Even more so, it means you have to drop 3 players just to make the trade work.





As of right now Beltran isn't even going to play in the Grapefruit league:


http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/rumors/post/...





Having knees cleaned out could really turn the season in a bad way.





I wouldn't do the trade for 1 reason. You don't have any guys you can really drop. Granted this seems like your missing a bench, but even if you aren't, giving up Beltran for Rowand and crap doesn't exactly seem like a fair trade. I would keep Beltran and hope he hits 100% by the time the season starts.





Good luck!!
Reply:do it, loney and rowand alone are worth beltran
Reply:shsdffhadfjjfdflfdhasdfkl
Reply:No way. Do not give up Beltran for that trash. Glaus had a nice career, but he's not the player he was, and you certainly don't need him. Loney is unproven, and probably won't outperform Youkilis this year. Rowand is leaving a packed lineup for the offensive wasteland of San francisco. Billingsley is steady, but nowhere near a superstar. DO NOT TRADE QUALITY FOR QUANTITY!
Reply:I would do just Aaron Rowand for Carlos Beltan so you are getting the better part of the deal.
Reply:Don't do it. You have a nice team already. If you do accept, then you'll drop some nice players from your roster and thats a bad idea.
Reply:your team is pretty solid, I would keep Beltran.
Reply:Hawk Nelson can be your friend too!


www.hawknelsonismyfriend.com


eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeehappyy...
Reply:What i dont understand......
Reply:Your team is already solid, reject the trade.