How fair is this trade proposal?

Which side would you prefer?





Giving up...





R. Zimmerman WAS 3B


C. Jones ATL 3B


J. Giambi NYY 1B


S. Kazmir TB SP


C. Hamels PHI SP





Asking for...





D. Ortiz BOS 1B


D. Wright NYM 3B


A. Wainwright STL SP


J. Maine NYM SP








My other pitchers are J. Santana MIN, J. Bonderman DET, C.C. Sabathia CLE, J. Beckett BOS %26amp; A. Pettite NYY. That's why i can afford to lose Hamels %26amp; Kazmir. On offense i've also got Crawford, Morneau %26amp; Tejada.

How fair is this trade proposal?
Slated in your favor even if you are giving up Morneau. Wright outmatches Zimmerman, Ortiz beats Morneau, Wainwright/Maine beat Kazmir/Hamels. And they beat them by so much they're still ahead even when Jones is thrown in. And here's another part to the deal-It's not like you're losing 30 HR (about how many chipper will get). You're getting rid of Chipper's 30 but that frees up a spot to pick up a FA who will hit around 20...meaning that the extra throw in doesn't hurt you all that much (it also doesn't help your opponent that much because he has to drop someone)
Reply:Nice job man. I think he will accept, and you will still come out looking good.
Reply:It's fair, but Zimmerman and Jones play the same position. So they are like 1 player unless they have a weaker hitter at the utility spot.
Reply:i think that is a fair trade. Getting 2 hitters that are studs.
Reply:that is good for u bc wainwright will be a stud and john maine is an ok pitcher. but u would get ortiz one of the most powerful hitters and wright the best 3rd basman so i think u should do it