Should I make this fantasy baseball trade?

I'd be giving up Adrian Beltre and Erik Bedard and in return getting getting Joe Blanton, Troy Glaus and Geovany Soto.





This is my current team:





C J.R. Towles, Hou C


1B Ryan Howard, Phi 1B


2B Chase Utley, Phi 2B


3B Adrian Beltre, Sea 3B


SS Jimmy Rollins, Phi SS


IF Albert Pujols, StL 1B


LF Michael Bourn, Hou LF


CF Curtis Granderson*, Det CF


RF Delmon Young, Min RF


OF Torii Hunter, LAA CF


UTIL Travis Hafner, Cle DH


P Troy Percival, TB RP


P Jeremy Guthrie, Bal SP


SP Erik Bedard, Sea SP


SP Aaron Harang, Cin SP


SP Chris Young, SD SP


SP Gil Meche, KC SP


SP Rich Harden, Oak SP


RP Rafael Betancourt, Cle RP


RP Carlos Villanueva, Mil RP


RP Jonathan Broxton, LAD RP


Bench Edgar Renteria, Det SS


Bench Alex Gordon, KC 3B


Bench Jeff Kent, LAD 2B





Thanks!

Should I make this fantasy baseball trade?
Definetely don't make that trade. You're giving up the two best players in the deal by a mile.





Bedard is usually taken before the 40th pick, and is arguably a top 3 pitcher. Beltre is also a quiet four category contributor. Blanton is decent, Soto has potential, and Glaus is terrible. Don't make this trade.





Hope I helped!
Reply:No I wouldn't. The best players are the ones you are giving up. I think Beltre will be big this year. I don't expect great things out of Bedard but he is still better than blanton. Soto is just as unproven as towles.
Reply:Your giving up a top 50 player (Bedard) for 3 players with an O-rank of 182 or worse. Beltre is also close to a top 100 player...there is no reason to do this trade. Keep your better players and don't get ripped off.
Reply:That could be a hard one, Glaus wont play 100 games this year but u need saves and giving up Bedard wont hurt u too bad cause u still have a good starting staff. All in all u needing save and Soto have a good chance to get a bunch of saves. I would do it will help out in the long run.
Reply:That's a tough one, but I wouldn't make that deal, plus you would have to drop another player since your getting three for two.
Reply:DONT make this trade. Beltre is a proven top 7 3B nabbing 20hr and 90 rbi's easily. Joe Blanton is an average pitcher on a horrible team....Glaus is at the tail end of his career, and Soto is a solid catcher but perhaps overrated and unproven. Your team is stacked and solid as it is, ESPECIALLY with 230K pitcher Erik Bedard. Dont pull the trigger and keep your well-rounded team in tact.

clematis