All-Star MLB Playoff Bracket, who wins?

NL West:





C: Russell Martin LAD


1B: Adrian Gonzalez SDP


2B: Orlando Cabrera ARZ


SS: Troy Tulowitzki COL


3B: Garrett Atkins COL


OF: Matt Holliday COL


OF: Chris Young ARZ


OF: Eric Byrnes ARZ/Brad Hawpe COL





SP: Brandon Webb ARZ


SP: Dan Haren ARZ


SP: Jake Peavy SDP


SP: Chris Young SDP


SP: Brad Penny LAD/Tim Lincecum SFG


CL: Takashi Saito LAD





versus





NL Central





C: Geovany Soto CHC


1B: Prince Fielder MIL (that's right, no Pujols)


2B: Brandon Phillips CIN


3B: Aramis Ramirez CHC


SS: Miguel Tejada HOU


OF: Lance Berkman HOU


OF: Carlos Lee HOU


OF: Alfonso Soriano CHC





SP: Carlos Zambrano CHC


SP: Roy Oswalt HOU


SP: Aaron Harang CIN


SP: Ben Sheets MIL


SP: Adam Wainwright STL


CL: Francisco Cordero CIN

All-Star MLB Playoff Bracket, who wins?
I'd take the NL West.





The Central has the slight edge in hitting, even with unproven Soto starting. But, the West has way better pitching, and pitching, in my opinion, is more important than hitting.
Reply:What an idiot... Matt Cain deserves to be on that list Report It

Reply:NL West pitching dominates Report It

Reply:I would go with the West, simply because of their pitching. The central has the better hitting, but the West's pitching is really deep and includes 2 of the top 4 pitchers in baseball in Webb and Peavy.
Reply:NL Central





i like the west pitching but the sticks in the Central are good enough to hit 'em
Reply:central
Reply:NL West, pitching wins and those starters besides Lincecum are top 15 in baseball. Oswalt and Zambrano are the only top 15 pitchers in the NL Central in my opinion.