Should I do this deal?

Hes giving me Craig Monroe,Tim Hudson,and Brett Myers and I would be giving him in return Delmon Young,A.J. Burnett,and Kevin Millwood..Below is my lineup.. Would this improve my team?





C Brian McCann


(Atl - C)


1B Derrek Lee


(ChC - 1B)


2B Luis Castillo


(Min - 2B)


3B Miguel Cabrera


(Fla - 3B)


SS Hanley Ramírez


(Fla - SS)


OF Carl Crawford


(TB - OF)


OF Andruw Jones


(Atl - OF)


OF Bobby Abreu


(NYY-OF)


Util Jim Thome


(CWS-Util)


SP Chuck James


(Atl-SP)


SP Kevin Millwood


(Tex-SP)


RP Tom Gordon


(Phi-RP)


RP Jorge Julio


(Fla-RP)


P Adam Wainwright


(Stl-RP)


P Sallomon Torres


(Pit-RP)


P AJ Burnett


(Tor-SP)


BN Joel Zumaya


BN Mike Gonzalez


BN Gil Meche

Should I do this deal?
I would say no. I mean, I think Delmon Young's going to have a breakout year and even if he wasn't, I wouldn't trade him for Monroe. I think Brett Myers would be an upgrade at SP. If I were you I'd look to improve at 2B before I swapped reserve outfielders. And you can find decent starting pitchers all over the place without giving up Burnett and Millwood.
Reply:It wouldn't make much of a difference.Go for it anyway
Reply:Probably, go for it.
Reply:i would say flip a coin....pretty even trade.....but if its a keeper league than "no" because of young's potential. hudson and burnett have injury problems and millwood is over the hill, so that leaves monroe for young. young is an up and coming player while monroe is a very good 4th outfielder for your team. good luck
Reply:it is a fair trade, but i dont know how much it will improve your team. the players involved are pretty much within the same talent range. you do need some 2B help though!

carnation